Comparisons

Which safeguards should be non-negotiable?

Screening is one layer, not the complete system. The US Department of Justice’s youth-organization guidance calls for continuing monitoring, supervision and re-screening alongside background screening. CDC guidance also separates screening from conduct rules, safe environments, responses to concerns and training. (ojp.gov)

Explore the comparison in this briefing

Requirement

01 / 7 options

Named adult and screening

Evidence to request
Identity, relevant references, check date and scope, responsibility for substitutes
Reason to pause
The family cannot establish who will teach or what screening occurred

Compare each option against the same criteria. The complete table and qualifications remain in the briefing.

The following are recommended household requirements, not a safeguarding certification or a statement that every item is legally mandatory in every US jurisdiction.

Requirement Evidence to request Reason to pause
Named adult and screening Identity, relevant references, check date and scope, responsibility for substitutes The family cannot establish who will teach or what screening occurred
Parent-visible communication Approved channels, parent inclusion and rules for between-session contact Secret, disappearing or unapproved personal messaging is proposed
Tool eligibility Tool inventory, account owner and dated access conditions False ages, borrowed logins or unsupported exceptions are proposed
Data handling What is collected, where it goes, retention, deletion and model-training treatment The supplier cannot explain where recordings, prompts or project data are stored
Recording and publicity Separate recording, transcription and publication decisions Participation is treated as blanket permission for marketing or public identification
Escalation Named contact, concern-handling procedure and substitute coverage Nobody accepts responsibility for investigating a concern
Project release Parent approval process, data review, credentials and spending controls Public deployment is expected before these questions are resolved

Wyzant’s own policy explicitly warns that its background check is a database search with coverage limitations and is not a perfect safety solution. Do not transfer confidence from a marketplace badge to all aspects of the tutor’s suitability. (support.wyzant.com)

For in-person tuition, extend the brief to the venue, attendance and pickup arrangements, household access and insurance. Obtain state-specific advice before recording lessons or resolving legal questions about consent.

Can children under 13 use AI tools with a tutor?

There is no single age rule covering all AI tools. Check the actual product and workflow. These are access conditions, not assurances that the content or learning design is suitable.

Product/workflow Official position found What it means for selection
ChatGPT consumer use OpenAI’s terms require users to be at least 13, with parent or guardian permission if under 18. (openai.com) Do not approve a plan requiring a younger child to operate their own ChatGPT account.
ChatGPT in an under-13 educational context OpenAI’s help guidance says the actual interaction must be conducted by an adult. (help.openai.com) Ask who operates the tool; adult demonstration is not permission to hand over an adult login.
Claude consumer account Anthropic’s current help guidance requires users to be at least 18 to create and use an account. (support.claude.com) Parent approval alone does not satisfy that consumer-account age requirement.
Gemini Apps supervised account Google provides a parent-enabled route for children under 13 through Family Link, subject to supported availability and settings. (support.google.com) Verify the child’s actual account and device arrangement rather than assuming universal access.
An educational application using an API OpenAI publishes separate requirements for applications serving minors, including additional safeguards and a zero-data-retention condition before processing under-13 personal data. (developers.openai.com) “We use an API” is not sufficient evidence of a compliant or suitable child-facing service.

Google also warns that its filters are imperfect and recommends supervision and avoiding sensitive personal information in children’s chats. Eligibility should therefore be the beginning of the review, not its conclusion. (support.google.com)

Does COPPA or FERPA automatically cover private tutoring?

No blanket assurance follows from either acronym. COPPA concerns covered commercial websites and online services directed to children, or with actual knowledge of collecting personal information from children under 13. Whether a tutoring workflow is covered depends on the service and facts—not simply on calling the activity education. (govinfo.gov)

The amended COPPA Rule became effective on June 23, 2025, with a general compliance deadline of April 22, 2026, subject to specified exceptions. That deadline is already past; a supplier should not describe those amendments as merely forthcoming. (govinfo.gov)

FERPA applies to educational agencies and institutions receiving funds through programs administered by the US Department of Education. A household should not assume that privately purchased tutoring has FERPA protection merely because it is educational. School-linked arrangements require their own analysis. (studentprivacy.ed.gov)

This report is purchasing research, not legal advice. Ask the supplier to explain its applicable obligations and use qualified counsel for unresolved legal questions.

Sources cited on this page

  1. What You Need to Know about Background Screening: A Reference Guide for Youth-Serving Organizations and their Communities | Office of Justice Programs ↗ojp.gov
  2. Background Check Policy - Wyzant ↗support.wyzant.com
  3. Terms of Use | OpenAI ↗openai.com
  4. Is ChatGPT safe for all ages? | OpenAI Help Center ↗help.openai.com
  5. Minimum age requirement access restriction | Claude Help Center ↗support.claude.com
  6. Guide your child's Gemini Apps experience - Google For Families Help ↗support.google.com
  7. Under-18 guidance | OpenAI API ↗developers.openai.com
  8. Federal Register, Volume 90 Issue 76 (Tuesday, April 22, 2025) ↗govinfo.gov
  9. To which educational agencies or institutions does FERPA apply? | Protecting Student Privacy ↗studentprivacy.ed.gov