Shortlist two or three named instructors against the same brief. Ask explicitly for human, one-to-one teaching and whether the supplier accepts the child’s own project or teaches only its curriculum.
Explore the comparison in this briefing
Check
Identity and screening
- Evidence to request
- Who checked the instructor, when, in which jurisdictions and with what limitations?
- Household rule until resolved
- No unsupervised access while suitability remains unresolved.
Compare each option against the same criteria. The complete table and qualifications remain in the briefing.
That distinction is substantive: CodeWizardsHQ’s help page says its private courses provide individual instruction using its curriculum, but it does not offer tutoring outside that curriculum. A private format is therefore not automatically bespoke project mentorship. (intercom.help)
What evidence should each candidate provide?
Request:
- The proposed instructor’s identity, relevant technical experience and experience teaching the learner’s age band.
- Two suitable references, with permission to contact them.
- A proposed first-session activity and an explanation of how the mentor responds when a learner is stuck.
- A redacted progress-report example that distinguishes learner work from assistance.
- Written safety, communication, tool-use and commercial arrangements.
- Availability, substitution arrangements and who handles concerns.
Label each important finding document-supported, supplier assertion, observed in trial or not established. Missing evidence is not proof of misconduct, but some missing answers should prevent a lesson from starting.
What belongs on an online AI tutor safety checklist?
The following are recommended household requirements. NSPCC tutoring guidance supports references, conduct policies, clear supervision and a concern-reporting process; it is a UK best-practice reference, not US law. Wyzant’s US safety guidance also recommends background checks, references and adult presence for sessions involving minors. (learning.nspcc.org.uk)
| Check | Evidence to request | Household rule until resolved |
|---|---|---|
| Identity and screening | Who checked the instructor, when, in which jurisdictions and with what limitations? | No unsupervised access while suitability remains unresolved. |
| Communication | Approved lesson and messaging channels; who can see messages. | Keep parent-visible channels; do not permit disappearing messages or requests for secrecy. |
| Supervision | Where the learner and mentor will be; how an adult can join or interrupt. | Agree arrangements before the first meeting. |
| Recording and transcription | Purpose, access, storage, deletion and any AI note-taking service. | Default to no recording until separately agreed. |
| Data and publicity | What is collected, shared or published, and with whom. | No public portfolio, testimonial, image or voice use without separate approval. |
| Concerns and substitutions | Escalation contact and replacement procedure. | Give the child a clear way to stop a session and speak to a trusted adult. |
Do not mistake marketplace admission for a completed background check. Wyzant says checks are not required for initial tutor registration and explicitly describes coverage limitations. Check the named tutor’s status and screening date; a successful check is one input, not a safety guarantee. (support.wyzant.com)
Can children under 13 use AI tools with a tutor?
There is no universal answer. Check the exact product, account type, age and lesson workflow. The following reflects official pages reviewed for this guide:
| Product or workflow | Published position | Buyer action |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT individual account | Minimum age is 13, or the applicable minimum age; users under 18 need parent or guardian permission. Account credentials cannot be shared. | Do not use an adult’s account as a child’s personal login. (openai.com) |
| ChatGPT in education involving under-13s | OpenAI says the actual interaction must be conducted by an adult. | Describe an adult-operated demonstration, not independent child use. (help.openai.com) |
| Claude consumer account | Users must be at least 18 to create and use an account. | Reject a plan that requires a minor’s personal Claude account. (support.claude.com) |
| Gemini Apps for supervised children | Google describes parent-enabled access through Family Link for under-13s, subject to availability and feature restrictions. | Verify the actual supervised account and proposed features; Google warns that filters are imperfect. (support.google.com) |
A tutor-built application using an API needs a separate review; consumer-account rules do not describe every developer arrangement. OpenAI’s under-18 API guidance specifies additional safeguards and says personal data of children under 13 should not be processed without first implementing zero data retention. Ask who operates the application and how the applicable requirements are met. (developers.openai.com)
Also distinguish not used for model training from not retained. OpenAI’s consumer-data guidance, for example, says temporary chats may be retained for up to 30 days for safety purposes. (help.openai.com)
What should you ask about COPPA and FERPA?
COPPA covers certain commercial online operators collecting personal information from children under 13, including child-directed services and general-audience services with actual knowledge of such collection. Applicability depends on the operation and data flow—not simply whether the seller calls itself a tutor. Ask the supplier to explain its responsibilities and consent process rather than accepting an unexplained “COPPA compliant” badge. (ftc.gov)
The amended COPPA Rule’s general compliance deadline was April 22, 2026, with specified exceptions; that date has already passed. A proposal treating those amendments as only a future requirement needs updating. (govinfo.gov)
FERPA applies to educational agencies and institutions receiving funds under US Department of Education programs. Do not treat it as a blanket privacy regime for household-purchased tutoring; school-linked arrangements need separate consideration. (studentprivacy.ed.gov)
Stage exit: The named mentor and proposed workflow meet the household’s requirements. Unresolved safety or eligibility issues are not offset by technical prestige. Obtain qualified legal advice where the arrangement’s obligations are unclear.
Sources cited on this page
- Do you offer tutoring? | CodeWizardsHQ Help Center ↗intercom.help
- Safeguarding and child protection for tutors | NSPCC Learning ↗learning.nspcc.org.uk
- Background Check Policy - Wyzant ↗support.wyzant.com
- Terms of Use | OpenAI ↗openai.com
- Is ChatGPT safe for all ages? | OpenAI Help Center ↗help.openai.com
- Minimum age requirement access restriction | Claude Help Center ↗support.claude.com
- Guide your child's Gemini Apps experience - Google For Families Help ↗support.google.com
- Under-18 guidance | OpenAI API ↗developers.openai.com
- How OpenAI handles data in consumer services | OpenAI Help Center ↗help.openai.com
- Complying with COPPA: Frequently Asked Questions | Federal Trade Commission ↗ftc.gov
- Federal Register, Volume 90 Issue 76 (Tuesday, April 22, 2025) ↗govinfo.gov
- To which educational agencies or institutions does FERPA apply? | Protecting Student Privacy ↗studentprivacy.ed.gov