Renew when the learner wants to continue and evidence supports the next goal; reset when scope or teaching needs adjustment; replace when the relationship repeatedly fails the agreed requirements. A safety concern should be handled separately from an educational improvement plan.
Explore the comparison in this briefing
Decision
Renew
- Indicators to discuss
- Increasing independence, useful feedback, good rapport and a credible next objective
- Next action
- Approve another bounded block
Compare each option against the same criteria. The complete table and qualifications remain in the briefing.
Our proposed decision table:
| Decision | Indicators to discuss | Next action |
|---|---|---|
| Renew | Increasing independence, useful feedback, good rapport and a credible next objective | Approve another bounded block |
| Reset | Interest remains, but prerequisites, scope or session format are wrong | Reduce the project and specify a short review period |
| Replace | Repeated takeover, unexplained cancellations, poor response to feedback or continued lack of learning evidence | Arrange a handover and assess a new mentor |
| Pause immediately | Unresolved inappropriate contact, prohibited account use or undisclosed data sharing | Stop the affected activity and use the agreed escalation route |
A proposed four-session reset could cover: reassessing the starting point, repairing one prerequisite, rebuilding a small component, and demonstrating a related task.
Before switching, request files, dependencies, setup instructions, learning notes and a clear contribution record. Do not make the child repeat an entire onboarding process merely because the adults did not arrange a handover.
Sources and context
This page sets out the desk’s purchasing framework. Sources →