Direct questions

5. What questions should I ask a private AI tutor before hiring, and what should a trial look like?

Ask for demonstrations of teaching and judgment, not only descriptions of experience. A useful trial includes a small learner task, a moment of difficulty, and a short parent debrief.

Our proposed interview script:

  1. What would you assess before selecting a project?
  2. Which parts should the child complete independently?
  3. When would you introduce AI-generated code, and when would you withhold it?
  4. Can you explain a technical idea at this child’s level without relying on jargon?
  5. How would you respond if the learner says they understand but cannot make a small change?
  6. Which accounts, subscriptions and permissions are required?
  7. What contact is allowed outside lessons?
  8. What is recorded, retained or uploaded to AI systems?
  9. What evidence will appear in parent reports?
  10. What happens if the project proves too ambitious or the mentor changes?

Suggested 45-minute trial—not an educational standard:

  • 5 minutes: learner interests and starting point.
  • 10 minutes: explanation of one concept.
  • 20 minutes: a small task and a changed requirement.
  • 5 minutes: learner explanation in their own preferred format.
  • 5 minutes: parent debrief and next-step proposal.

For technical parents, an unfamiliar debugging example can reveal how the mentor reasons. For non-technical parents, watch whether the instructor asks the child to predict, explain and try—or simply takes over.

Do not turn the trial into a high-pressure exam. Allow diagrams, extra thinking time and agreed accessibility supports. The desk’s purpose is to observe the teaching relationship, not rank children.

Sources and context

This page sets out the desk’s purchasing framework. Sources →