Do-it-yourself game plans

How do you prove the child is learning rather than watching AI work?

Track assistance and test a small amount of transfer. Do not try to infer authorship or competence from the polish of a finished project.

Use a contribution record, not surveillance

After each session, complete a few lines:

Component or decision Learner contribution Mentor contribution AI contribution What the learner can now explain or change
Example: data-loading function Chose fields and changed a filter Explained an error Suggested an initial code draft Can alter the filter and explain the result

The purpose is honest attribution, not maximising a percentage labelled “child-written.” A learner can legitimately use assistance while still developing understanding; the record should make that assistance visible.

What should a useful parent report contain?

Ask for five short items:

  1. Goal practised: the capability, not just the feature completed.
  2. Learner action: something the child actually explained, decided or changed.
  3. Support used: demonstration, hint, code, AI draft or direct intervention.
  4. Current difficulty: one specific unresolved issue.
  5. Next step: the next small task and any required preparation.

A report saying only “excellent engagement; chatbot completed” is insufficient for this buying decision.

Try the 15-minute “explain, change, debug” check

Use familiar material and tell the learner the purpose beforehand:

  • Explain: “What information goes in, what comes out, and where might it fail?”
  • Change: “Can you make this small adjustment?”
  • Debug: “What would you inspect first if this result looked wrong?”
  • Reflect: “What did the mentor or AI supply that you could not yet do alone?”

Record the support needed: independent, verbal hint, worked example or direct completion. Do not use the result as a diagnosis or compare children against each other.

About a week later, invite a tiny related task with a changed input. This is a proposed household check of retention and transfer, not a validated test. Keep it brief and supportive.

For parents wanting background on this distinction, the January 2026 Screen Deep episode with learning-sciences researcher Adam Dubé discusses choosing educational technology and distinguishing learning support from offloading the work. Its page includes audio, a transcript and a YouTube route. (childrenandscreens.org)

Sources cited on this page

  1. Does AI Help Students Learn? | Adam Dubé, PhD - Children and Screens ↗childrenandscreens.org