Make safeguards and tool eligibility pass-or-pause conditions. Do not allow a strong technical score or prestigious affiliation to compensate for an unresolved critical issue.
Explore the comparison in this briefing
Product or service
ChatGPT
- Official position found
- OpenAI’s individual terms specify a minimum age of 13, or the applicable local minimum; under-18s need parent or guardian permission. Accounts must not be shared.
- Practical purchasing implication
- Do not create a false-age account or lend an adult login to the learner. (openai.com)
Compare each option against the same criteria. The complete table and qualifications remain in the briefing.
What should the household’s communication rules be?
A useful model is the U.S. Center for SafeSport’s emphasis on observable, interruptible interactions and transparent electronic communication. Its rules govern specified sporting contexts; they are not a nationwide private-tutoring law. The following adapts those principles into proposed household requirements. (maapp.uscenterforsafesport.org)
- Use a parent-visible scheduling and messaging channel.
- No disappearing messages, secret accounts or personal social-media relationships.
- Give the parent a disclosed ability to join or interrupt online sessions.
- For in-person sessions, choose an agreed common area with another responsible adult available.
- Set contact hours and a rule for between-session questions.
- Require approval before changing platforms, adding another adult or arranging an off-platform meeting.
- Explain to the child that they can stop a session or raise discomfort without losing access to learning.
- Identify a complaint contact outside the assigned mentor where an agency is involved.
These controls should apply to any substitute, not just the original instructor.
How do you check a private tutor’s background in the US?
Establish identity, screening scope, references and working behaviour separately. Ask who checked the mentor, when, in which jurisdictions and against which records. Obtain an appropriate verification or attestation rather than collecting sensitive identity documents into an ordinary household spreadsheet.
Wyzant provides a concrete warning against assumptions: it says a background check is not required simply to register as a tutor. Its optional check is listed at $15.99, and its policy expressly describes database-coverage limitations, including incomplete coverage of records and foreign history. A successful result is one input, not a safety guarantee. (support.wyzant.com)
For an independent hire, use a suitable screening provider and obtain advice about the applicable process. Employment background reports can trigger permission, disclosure and adverse-action requirements; the FTC explains these obligations for employers. Do not improvise an employment check through an informal people-search website. (consumer.ftc.gov)
For each reference, ask:
- What age and starting ability did the mentor teach?
- How did they respond when the learner struggled?
- What could the learner do independently by the end?
- Were communication, punctuality and boundaries reliable?
- Would you engage the same person again, and for what type of learner?
Ask permission before contacting references. Do not request another child’s recordings, school reports or identifiable project files as evidence.
Which AI tools can children actually use?
Check the exact product, account type and country—not merely the model name. The position found in the reviewed official pages is below. Recheck before account creation and whenever the workflow changes.
| Product or service | Official position found | Practical purchasing implication |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | OpenAI’s individual terms specify a minimum age of 13, or the applicable local minimum; under-18s need parent or guardian permission. Accounts must not be shared. | Do not create a false-age account or lend an adult login to the learner. (openai.com) |
| ChatGPT in education involving under-13s | OpenAI says the actual interaction must be conducted by an adult and cautions that outputs may be unsuitable. | Adult demonstration is not independent child access. Do not assume supervision alone authorises handing over control. (help.openai.com) |
| Gemini Apps | Google describes access for under-13s through supervised accounts, enabled by a parent using Family Link, subject to availability. It warns that filters are imperfect. | Verify the particular supervised account, device and features; this is not permission for every Google AI product. (support.google.com) |
| Claude consumer services | Anthropic’s consumer terms require users to be at least 18, or a higher applicable local minimum, and prohibit making an account available to someone else. | Do not treat parental permission as an under-18 consumer-account exception. (anthropic.com) |
| GitHub | GitHub’s account terms require users to be at least 13, with higher local minimums potentially applying. | For younger learners, use an appropriate alternative workflow rather than a false date of birth. (docs.github.com) |
A custom tutor-built application is not automatically a loophole. OpenAI’s under-18 API guidance calls for additional safeguards and says not to process under-13 personal data without first implementing zero data retention. Ask the operator for its actual compliance and safety arrangements rather than accepting “we use an API” as reassurance. (developers.openai.com)
What belongs in the tool and data inventory?
Create one row for every video platform, coding environment, AI service, repository, transcription service and hosting provider:
| Field | Required answer |
|---|---|
| Product and account type | Exact service and plan, not just “Google” or “AI” |
| Account holder and operator | Who owns the account, who uses it and who can administer it |
| Eligibility evidence | Official terms, date checked and permission required |
| Data entering the service | Prompts, code, names, images, voice, files or logs |
| Training and retention | Whether content may improve models; retention and deletion arrangements |
| Visibility | Private, shared with the mentor, shared with staff or public |
| Spending | Payer, alerts, enforceable limits and shutdown owner |
| Exit | Export, account closure, access removal and deletion process |
Do not confuse parental controls with full visibility. OpenAI’s current parental-control documentation says linking accounts does not give parents access to a teen’s conversations, history or real-time activity. Review the settings together and agree how lesson-related work will be shared. (help.openai.com)
Does COPPA apply to private online tutoring?
It depends on the operator and its data practices, not simply on calling the service tutoring. COPPA concerns covered commercial online services directed to under-13s, and general-audience services with actual knowledge that they collect personal information from under-13s. Ask the supplier which entity operates each child-facing service and what notice, consent, access and deletion process it uses. (ftc.gov)
The amended COPPA Rule became effective June 23, 2025, with the general compliance deadline April 22, 2026, apart from specified Safe Harbor provisions. That deadline is already past as of this review. Do not accept a proposal treating the amendments as a future implementation task. (govinfo.gov)
FERPA is different: the Department of Education explains that it applies to educational agencies and institutions receiving funds under its programmes. Do not assume privately purchased household tuition carries the same protections as a covered school arrangement; ask for the provider’s actual legal basis and contractual protections. (studentprivacy.ed.gov)
Legal boundary: obtain qualified advice for the actual states, parties and arrangements involved, particularly for recording, school-record access, independent hiring or public products used by children. This checklist is not legal clearance.
Should lessons be recorded?
The proposed default is no recording and no automated transcription. Use brief written progress notes and selected work samples instead.
If recording is genuinely needed, settle the purpose, applicable consent requirements, access, storage, retention, deletion and prohibition on marketing use before it begins. Obtain the learner’s age-appropriate agreement as well as the required adult permissions. Do not accept a broad publicity release as the price of receiving tuition.
Sources cited on this page
- How it Works MAAPP | U.S. Center for SafeSport ↗maapp.uscenterforsafesport.org
- Background Check Policy - Wyzant ↗support.wyzant.com
- Employer Background Checks and Your Rights | Consumer Advice ↗consumer.ftc.gov
- Terms of Use | OpenAI ↗openai.com
- Is ChatGPT safe for all ages? | OpenAI Help Center ↗help.openai.com
- Guide your child's Gemini Apps experience - Gemini Apps Help ↗support.google.com
- Consumer Terms of Service \ Anthropic ↗anthropic.com
- GitHub Terms of Service - GitHub Docs ↗docs.github.com
- Under-18 guidance | OpenAI API ↗developers.openai.com
- Managing parental controls in ChatGPT | OpenAI Help Center ↗help.openai.com
- Complying with COPPA: Frequently Asked Questions | Federal Trade Commission ↗ftc.gov
- Federal Register, Volume 90 Issue 76 (Tuesday, April 22, 2025) ↗govinfo.gov
- To which educational agencies or institutions does FERPA apply? | Protecting Student Privacy ↗studentprivacy.ed.gov