SECTION 08 OF 11 / Decision tools

Scorecard

Compare the named mentor against teaching evidence and non-negotiable gates.

Pages
12
Sources cited
24
Last updated
17 November 2026
A learner explaining a code decision on a whiteboard
Mentor evidence scorecard

Compare the evidence behind the offer.

Clear the five gates first. Rate only defensible evidence from 0 to 4; use U when it is not established.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1 Learner understanding and ownership 22.0%2 Teaching and feedback 18.0%3 Relevant technical competence 15.0%4 Readiness, scope and progression 10.0%5 Learner rapport, agency and accessibility 10.0%6 Evaluation and responsible technical judgment 8.0%7 Evidence-based parent reporting 7.0%8 Continuity and household coordination 5.0%9 Commercial clarity and total commitment 5.0%

The supplied weights total 100. Edited weights are proportionally normalised to 100; minimum criterion ratings and gates still apply.

Three-provider comparison. Unknown evidence stays U and does not become a zero-quality rating.
Gate or criterionWeight
01 / Non-negotiable gates · no weighted points
G1. Named adult and suitability checks

Identity matched to the assigned mentor; relevant experience; references from comparable teaching; screening provider, date, scope and limitations; who reviews concerns and substitutes.

Hold: screening or identity cannot yet be established. Fail: material misrepresentation or refusal to meet the household’s agreed suitability requirements.

—
G2. Contact boundaries and escalation

Parent-visible approved communication; no disappearing or secret channels; agreed contact hours; sessions observable or interruptible by a responsible adult; a concern-reporting route that does not depend solely on the mentor.

Requests for secrecy, unauthorized private contact, resistance to reasonable oversight, or no workable escalation arrangement. For a solo mentor, agree a separate adult route and an immediate pause procedure.

—
G3. Tool and account eligibility

Exact products and features, account type, intended user, applicable age terms, parental permissions and a dated check of official documentation.

False ages, shared credentials where prohibited, or treating parental consent as an override of a product’s minimum age.

—
G4. Data, recording and publicity

Data-flow inventory; purpose and recipients; retention/deletion arrangements; training-use settings; separate decisions about recordings, transcription, AI meeting assistants and public portfolios.

Unexplained uploads, mandatory publicity without a learning need, hidden recording/transcription, or no answer about who receives child data. Use a no-recording alternative if recording cannot be appropriately authorized.

—
G5. Project permissions and deployment

Approved dataset and services; no confidential employer material; defined access permissions; adult-controlled spending; ownership/export arrangements; private demonstration as the default; separate release approval.

Exposed credentials, uncontrolled spending, unauthorized external actions, personal-data collection without review, or public deployment before approval. A non-deployed project can pass by explicitly excluding those activities.

—
02 / Teaching, learning and delivery evidence
1. Learner understanding and ownership

Weak · 0–1: Only the finished project is shown; the learner cannot explain an agreed component; mentor and AI contributions are obscured.

Adequate · 2: The learner explains a familiar example and makes a change with substantial guidance; contributions are recorded.

Strong · 3–4: The learner explains choices, changes a bounded requirement and diagnoses a simple fault. A 4 requires evidence of retention or transfer at a later session, not just an immediate repeat.

2. Teaching and feedback

Weak · 0–1: The mentor lectures, takes over, supplies answers immediately or responds poorly to confusion.

Adequate · 2: Explanations are understandable and feedback is constructive, but adaptation or checking of understanding is inconsistent.

Strong · 3–4: The mentor diagnoses misconceptions, gives proportionate hints, allows thinking time and adjusts the task. Strong practice is repeated rather than performed only in a showcase lesson.

3. Relevant technical competence

Weak · 0–1: The mentor cannot explain their own example, relies on unexplained generated code or makes unsupported capability claims.

Adequate · 2: The mentor can explain and modify the proposed stack, with identifiable limits or specialist gaps.

Strong · 3–4: The mentor debugs an unfamiliar, appropriate example; explains data, model and application boundaries; tests fixes; and acknowledges uncertainty. Depth matches the project rather than the résumé.

4. Readiness, scope and progression

Weak · 0–1: The same ambitious project is offered regardless of starting skills; prerequisites and between-session work are undefined.

Adequate · 2: A baseline and milestones exist, but scope reduction, dependencies or the learner-owned core need clarification.

Strong · 3–4: The plan identifies prerequisites, a small achievable core, observable learning milestones, optional extensions and a fallback if progress is slower than expected.

5. Learner rapport, agency and accessibility

Weak · 0–1: The learner is reluctant, sidelined or pressured; reasonable communication or accessibility needs are dismissed.

Adequate · 2: The learner is comfortable and participates, but has little meaningful choice or ownership.

Strong · 3–4: The learner helps choose goals, feels able to ask questions and make mistakes, and wants to continue. The mentor adapts pace and participation without turning enrichment into an examination.

6. Evaluation and responsible technical judgment

Weak · 0–1: Success means one impressive demonstration; limitations, failed cases and release decisions are ignored.

Adequate · 2: The plan includes basic tests and limitations, but lacks a clear comparison, failure analysis or release rationale.

Strong · 3–4: The learner and mentor compare alternatives, test unseen or difficult cases, document failures and explain when not to use AI or publish the project. Any actual unsafe practice triggers a gate review, not merely a low score.

7. Evidence-based parent reporting

Weak · 0–1: Updates describe enthusiasm, hours or features without showing what the learner understands.

Adequate · 2: Updates connect activities to goals but inconsistently distinguish independent work from assistance.

Strong · 3–4: Reports show the baseline, new capability, assistance received, learner/mentor/AI contributions, unresolved difficulty and the next learning target. Evidence can be reviewed without routine recording.

8. Continuity and household coordination

Weak · 0–1: The assigned mentor is unclear; scheduling, substitution and handover arrangements are vague.

Adequate · 2: A named mentor, schedule and contact exist, but absence or replacement arrangements are incomplete.

Strong · 3–4: Availability, response expectations, holiday arrangements and substitutions are agreed; transferable notes and project files make an orderly handover possible. An independent mentor may satisfy this through a clear exit plan rather than an agency bench.

9. Commercial clarity and total commitment

Weak · 0–1: The quote obscures lesson length, preparation charges, expiry, recurring payments or cancellation exposure.

Adequate · 2: Core prices are clear, with a small number of unresolved extras or exit terms.

Strong · 3–4: The household can calculate scheduled teaching hours, expected expenditure, cancellation exposure and exit cost. Included support, tools, usage charges and ownership terms are explicit.

Provider A0.0 / 100Incomplete evidence

Below 65 · 65–74 · 75–84 · 85–100

Evidence coverage
0.0%
Unresolved weight
100.0
Possible scoring range
0.0–100.0
Gate evidence missing

Hold the affected activity. Missing gate evidence is not clearance.

Provider B0.0 / 100Incomplete evidence

Below 65 · 65–74 · 75–84 · 85–100

Evidence coverage
0.0%
Unresolved weight
100.0
Possible scoring range
0.0–100.0
Gate evidence missing

Hold the affected activity. Missing gate evidence is not clearance.

Provider C0.0 / 100Incomplete evidence

Below 65 · 65–74 · 75–84 · 85–100

Evidence coverage
0.0%
Unresolved weight
100.0
Possible scoring range
0.0–100.0
Gate evidence missing

Hold the affected activity. Missing gate evidence is not clearance.

A complete longer-commitment assessment requires all nine criteria established, none below 2, and criteria 1, 2, 3 and 5 at least 3. The weights and cutoffs are editorial decision rules. Do not enter child identifiers or confidential material. Nothing is saved unless you explicitly choose to save it.

READ THE FULL RESEARCH

In this section

01

How should you choose an AI mentor for your child?

Check safeguarding and tool eligibility first, then score the named mentor against a 100-point rubric that gives the most weight to demonstrable learning and teaching quality.

Read →
02

What should the weighted scorecard measure?

Allocate 40 points to learning evidence and teaching quality, 15 to technical competence, and the remaining 45 to fit, evaluation, reporting and delivery.

Read →
03

How do you calculate a score without rewarding unsupported claims?

Score the evidence you have, and show what remains unknown.

Read →
04

Which safety gates must be cleared before lessons begin?

Use pass, hold or fail—not weighted points.

Read →
05

What should a trial actually test?

Test how the mentor teaches through difficulty and what the learner can subsequently do—not just whether the mentor can produce a working demonstration.

Read →
06

What do supplier pages establish—and what do they leave unanswered?

Published offers are useful sourcing evidence, but they should not receive the same weight as named-mentor observations.

Read →
07

How should you compare private AI tuition prices and package value?

Compare the complete commitment and usable teaching time, then judge value alongside learning evidence.

Read →
08

What does a completed comparison look like?

A technically stronger candidate can still be the weaker educational purchase.

Read →
09

When should you renew, reset or replace the mentor?

Renew against the agreed learning targets and actual delivery, not the volume of new features.

Read →
10

What should the assistant put in the parent’s approval pack?

One decision page plus a linked evidence file is enough.

Read →

What are the limits of this research?

This document draws on official platform policies, federal guidance, education research, supplier offers and recruitment material.

Read →

Sources

Review the original sources and evidence behind this section.

Read →
RESEARCH QUALITY

The desk’s assessment of this research.
These scores do not rate providers.

10/10Buyer relevance
9/10Depth
9/10Question coverage
9/10Sources