Scorecard

Which safety gates must be cleared before lessons begin?

Use pass, hold or fail—not weighted points. Pass means the agreed evidence and operating arrangements are in place for the defined activity; it does not mean risk has been eliminated.

The US Department of Justice’s background-screening guide describes layered screening and emphasizes ongoing supervision, monitoring and re-screening. A background check should therefore be treated as one control, not a complete judgment of suitability. (ojp.gov)

The following are recommended household requirements, not a statement that every item is legally mandatory in every US state.

Gate Evidence to request Hold or fail indicators
G1. Named adult and suitability checks Identity matched to the assigned mentor; relevant experience; references from comparable teaching; screening provider, date, scope and limitations; who reviews concerns and substitutes. Hold: screening or identity cannot yet be established. Fail: material misrepresentation or refusal to meet the household’s agreed suitability requirements.
G2. Contact boundaries and escalation Parent-visible approved communication; no disappearing or secret channels; agreed contact hours; sessions observable or interruptible by a responsible adult; a concern-reporting route that does not depend solely on the mentor. Requests for secrecy, unauthorized private contact, resistance to reasonable oversight, or no workable escalation arrangement. For a solo mentor, agree a separate adult route and an immediate pause procedure.
G3. Tool and account eligibility Exact products and features, account type, intended user, applicable age terms, parental permissions and a dated check of official documentation. False ages, shared credentials where prohibited, or treating parental consent as an override of a product’s minimum age.
G4. Data, recording and publicity Data-flow inventory; purpose and recipients; retention/deletion arrangements; training-use settings; separate decisions about recordings, transcription, AI meeting assistants and public portfolios. Unexplained uploads, mandatory publicity without a learning need, hidden recording/transcription, or no answer about who receives child data. Use a no-recording alternative if recording cannot be appropriately authorized.
G5. Project permissions and deployment Approved dataset and services; no confidential employer material; defined access permissions; adult-controlled spending; ownership/export arrangements; private demonstration as the default; separate release approval. Exposed credentials, uncontrolled spending, unauthorized external actions, personal-data collection without review, or public deployment before approval. A non-deployed project can pass by explicitly excluding those activities.

Ask for confirmation sufficient to assess screening without collecting the mentor’s Social Security number or distributing raw background reports around the household. Keep the research file proportionate and access-controlled.

Can children under 13 use AI tools with a tutor?

There is no universal answer: check the exact service and account arrangement. The following official policies were reviewed for this edition; they are eligibility information, not recommendations that a tool is educationally appropriate.

Product or service What the official source establishes Scorecard implication
ChatGPT consumer services OpenAI’s terms require users to be at least 13, or the applicable higher minimum age, and users under 18 to have parent or guardian permission. Account credentials must not be shared. Its education guidance says actual ChatGPT interaction for under-13 educational use must be conducted by an adult. A parent’s permission does not authorize a 12-year-old to operate an adult’s ChatGPT account. Distinguish an adult-operated demonstration from direct child use. (openai.com)
Claude consumer accounts Anthropic’s help documentation requires users to be at least 18 to create and use a Claude account. A plan requiring a 14- or 17-year-old to use their own consumer Claude account does not clear the eligibility gate. (support.claude.com)
Gemini Apps with supervised accounts Google describes parent-enabled access for under-13 supervised accounts through Family Link, while noting availability and feature limitations and imperfect content filtering. Verify the actual supervised account, device, region and features. Do not generalize this permission to every Google AI product. (support.google.com)
GitHub GitHub’s terms require users to be at least 13 and prohibit sharing a single login between multiple people. Check repository and collaboration accounts as well as the chatbot. For a younger learner, specify an alternative workflow rather than an inaccurate birth date. (docs.github.com)

An API-based educational application is a separate diligence question. OpenAI’s under-18 API guidance calls for additional safeguards and says personal data of children under 13, or the applicable digital-consent age, should not be processed without first implementing zero data retention. That condition is not blanket permission or a substitute for the application operator’s other obligations. (developers.openai.com)

Does COPPA or FERPA make a private tutor safe?

No compliance label replaces the operational review above. COPPA concerns covered commercial online services directed to children under 13 or knowingly collecting their personal information. The amended rule became effective June 23, 2025, with the general compliance deadline April 22, 2026—already past at this research date—and includes strengthened security and retention obligations. Applicability depends on the actual service and data practices. (govinfo.gov)

FERPA applies to educational agencies and institutions receiving funds through US Department of Education programs. It is not a blanket privacy guarantee for a household’s private tutoring purchase; school-linked arrangements require separate analysis. (studentprivacy.ed.gov)

Ask qualified counsel to resolve uncertain recording, privacy, reporting or cross-state issues. This scorecard is purchasing guidance, not legal clearance.

Sources cited on this page

  1. What You Need to Know about Background Screening: A Reference Guide for Youth-Serving Organizations and their Communities | Office of Justice Programs ↗ojp.gov
  2. Terms of Use | OpenAI ↗openai.com
  3. Minimum age requirement access restriction | Claude Help Center ↗support.claude.com
  4. Guide your child's Gemini Apps experience - Gemini Apps Help ↗support.google.com
  5. GitHub Terms of Service - GitHub Docs ↗docs.github.com
  6. Under-18 guidance | OpenAI API ↗developers.openai.com
  7. Federal Register, Volume 90 Issue 76 (Tuesday, April 22, 2025) ↗govinfo.gov
  8. To which educational agencies or institutions does FERPA apply? | Protecting Student Privacy ↗studentprivacy.ed.gov