Renew against the agreed learning targets and actual delivery, not the volume of new features. Re-run the scorecard before the next material payment commitment and whenever the mentor, tools or project scope change.
Renew when
- Every applicable gate remains clear.
- The learner wants to continue.
- The completed score meets the household’s agreed threshold and minimum criterion scores.
- At least one agreed capability is demonstrably more independent than at baseline.
- The next block has a bounded learning goal and an explicit cost.
- Contributions, files and progress notes remain accessible to the household.
Reset when
The match appears workable but the project is too broad, prerequisites were missed or evidence remains thin. Agree a short corrective block with one or two specific changes—for example, a smaller learner-owned component and a delayed explanation task—rather than buying more of the unchanged plan.
Do not treat slower progress alone as mentor failure. Revisit the starting assessment, opportunities to practice, task difficulty and necessary support before attributing cause.
Replace or pause when
There is an unresolved safety issue, repeated boundary non-compliance, material misrepresentation, persistent mentor takeover despite an agreed reset, or the learner does not want to continue. Suspend the relevant activity immediately when a gate is breached; educational scoring is not a reason to defer a safety decision.
For a replacement, require an orderly handover: current files, dependencies, approved accounts, contribution notes, learning baseline, unfinished work and remaining financial obligations. Do not require the child to repeat the entire project merely to generate a new supplier showcase.
Sources and context
This page sets out the desk’s purchasing framework. What are the limits of this research? → Sources →