Scorecard

What does a completed comparison look like?

A technically stronger candidate can still be the weaker educational purchase. The following is a synthetic calculation, not an assessment of real suppliers. Assume both candidates have cleared all applicable gates and have complete evidence after a pilot.

Criterion Weight Candidate A: impressive builder, weak teaching Candidate B: evidence-led mentor
Learner understanding and ownership 22 1 4
Teaching and feedback 18 1 4
Relevant technical competence 15 4 3
Readiness, scope and progression 10 2 4
Rapport, agency and accessibility 10 3 3
Evaluation and technical judgment 8 1 3
Parent reporting 7 1 3
Continuity and coordination 5 3 3
Commercial clarity 5 2 3
Weighted total 100 47.5 87.5

Candidate B’s ratings of 4 assume repeated supporting observations. They cannot be awarded for a persuasive first consultation.

Candidate A is not recommended for the longer engagement despite excellent technical competence. Candidate B is a stronger purchase under this methodology, provided the child wants to continue and the next block remains within the demonstrated scope.

A third supplier with an excellent proposal but no named-mentor observation should be shown separately as incomplete. Do not fill its unknowns with average scores to make the shortlist look finished.

Sources and context

This page sets out the desk’s purchasing framework. What are the limits of this research? → Sources →